Bemanistyle [dot] com Forums - View Single Post - Challenge Round

#Infinity · 08-30-2006, 01:35 AM

Discovolante: I hate to break it to you, but I disagree with several of your ratings. It seems that you gave several songs "perfect" scores, perhaps because you were intrigued by unique solo patterns that you aren't used to. I personally found stepcharts such as 24 to be okay, but rather bland, yet you still give it an extremely high rating. I also thought you could've rated stuff such as Gasolina higher. While it might have doublestepping (though maybe you'll discover it to not have it if you play a few more times), I believe it should be essential to appreciate the uniqueness of simfiles such as it. In my defense, I believe the same applies with my entry.

Don't worry though, you put it all together in one night. If you change your mind after discovering more bad things and realize how interesting some of your lower-rated simfiles are, you may change your review.

pokecapn: Ah, I now see your point in redesigning Radio Star's graphics. You truly made it look like something that came right out of a DDR Solo mix. Very clever. Expect an extremely high rating from me once I complete my review.

08-30-2006, 01:35 AM	#6
#Infinity //bemanistyle::[Member] #Infinity is offline Join Date: Jun 2006 #Infinity's Collection Posts: 334 Marketplace Rating: 0	Discovolante: I hate to break it to you, but I disagree with several of your ratings. It seems that you gave several songs "perfect" scores, perhaps because you were intrigued by unique solo patterns that you aren't used to. I personally found stepcharts such as 24 to be okay, but rather bland, yet you still give it an extremely high rating. I also thought you could've rated stuff such as Gasolina higher. While it might have doublestepping (though maybe you'll discover it to not have it if you play a few more times), I believe it should be essential to appreciate the uniqueness of simfiles such as it. In my defense, I believe the same applies with my entry. Don't worry though, you put it all together in one night. If you change your mind after discovering more bad things and realize how interesting some of your lower-rated simfiles are, you may change your review. pokecapn: Ah, I now see your point in redesigning Radio Star's graphics. You truly made it look like something that came right out of a DDR Solo mix. Very clever. Expect an extremely high rating from me once I complete my review. __________________ Latest Simfile Release: