[hamm]

Originally Posted by Discovolante

First done, as usual.

Ahem, see ITG Bracket PR.

First off, how I'm rating. I'm stealing Discovolante's rating system but changing some of the amounts.

How well does it fit your theme (ITG, KB etc.)? Possible 1 points
How well do you utilize the solo layout? Possible 3 points
Is it technically well made (good flow, etc.)? 4 points
Is it enjoyable? 12 points

For files with changes, the last 12 points will be split up, so 7 to enjoyability, 5 to the overall rating of the changes. For new Oni files

this will not apply because they are different songs entirely. Also I'm not really gonna count art towards "change" points because that's not

being judged here.

Copy-pasted. Hell yeah.

And, I've worked myself up to be able to play and pass most of these files. I can't pass either KB files, but I got the rest down.

OH and also, I'm definately not suited to judge the DDR division, I don't play DDR anymore, and I tend to find it all the same. So, ITG division and KB division here it goes.

KB bracket division dealie

Arti - Paranoia Sky

Theme: I can't pass it, but it does seem a lot easier than any other KB files, but still 1/1
Extra arrows: They're there, and they're used a lot. Unfortunately not in any really original ways. 2/3
Tech: Tech is good, all the arrows have something to em. 4/4
Funliness: It's good, but it's almost paddable. That and I didn't like the little 16th run at the end to the very quiet notes. 8/12
Overall: 15/20

Eggman - Domino

Theme: Once again, I can't pass it, but this one seems more on par with other KB files. 1/1
Extra arrows: They're used really well, especially in the first set of 16th note runs. 3/3
Tech: Tech is also good, not much to say about KB files 4/4
Changes: I'm glad you fixed the BPM and Gap. 5/5
Funliness: It's fun and it's really quite hard. Basically nothing I didn't like 7/7
Overall: 20/20

ITG Bracket

Akira - Inner Universe

Theme: Yup, It's ITG. 1/1
Extra arrows: They're used, but not really as anything special. 2/3
Tech: There's a couple of really unnecessary hands, and like one shady crossover. 2/4
Changes: Good video, synching fix is always good 5/5
Funliness: It really reminds me of a DDR chart with hands added. Didn't like it. 2/7
Overall: 12/20

alphabet55 - Jump

Theme: ... 1/1
Extra arrows: I like em, especially in your runs, they're quite good. 3/3
Tech: Eh... I see what you were trying to do with the "Jump!" but I think it would have gone better if there weren't 8th notes after the

mines, they're hellish to time. 2/4
Changes: Bleh your BG is better than mine was. Looks a lot like the ITG Wannabe background for Jump. 5/5
Funliness: Streams were fun but I didn't like what you did with the 2nd chorus 4/7
Overall: 15/20

Discovolante - Little Little Princess

Theme: Gadzooks! This looks like ITG to me! 1/1
Extra arrows: Yeah, they're really used nicely, and not in excess either 3/3
Tech: Good good. It's like a happy Machinae Supremacy chart. Love what you did during the instrumental. 4/4
Funliness: Good, I like it with the exception of the hands that were meant to be cheated. so, 10/12
Overall: 18/20

(Note: I didn't use the category for changes because the only change he made was removing an arbitrary speedup in which he has no arrows. If I

did, it'd just be 5/5 and 5/7 resulting in the same overall score.)

Hamm - Together
My file is win-good.

Ike Pie - Tori No Uta
Theme: Yup. 1/1
Extra Arrows: Used and used well, they present some interesting crossovers 3/3
Tech: Works. Nothing's too bad. 4/4
Funliness: Only qualm was the ending where you're like backwards 10/12
Overall: 18/20

jammitch! - Kagekiha
Theme: Do I really have to say anything here? 1/1
Extra arrows: Used, balanced, and not bad. 3/3
Tech: Eh, some of the more complicated crossovers are kinda bad, and the first slowdown, I think is unnecessary. 2/4
Changes: Looks like the syncing is better and the stop is gone, but where is the video? And.. what's with the arbitrary speed up? 3/5
Funliness: Eh, it was pretty fun. 7/7
Overall: 16/20

Rob00996 - video Out C
Theme: 1/1
Extra arrows: Thery're used, but not used until the end during the freeze-turns 2/3
Tech: what's with the speed up in the middle and the one at the end? 2/4
Funliness: I'm really not feeling this one, I don't find it too fun, and it's way too gimmicky 8/12
Overall: 14/20

sanchny - DREAM OF YOU
Theme: 1/1
Extra arrows: Eh, no interesting things here, for the most part this song cam be done without turning yourself. 1/3
Tech: One really hairy crossover at a high BPM and then like 8th notes for most of the song. no like. 2/4
Funliness: Eh, it's kinda fun with the runs, but it only has two and isn't very solid. 9/12
Overall: 13/20

Xythar - Inspiration
Theme: 1/1
Extra arrows: Wow, if there were extra credit for creative use, this would get it. 3/3
Tech: There were one or two short runs in the beginning that didn't seem right to me. 3/4
Changes: ITG song length eh, it's a legitimate change. No real opinion on it though 5/5
Funliness: Seems a bit offsync. aside from that no real complaints 6/7
Overall: 18/20

So there you go everybody. PR #2.

Edit: I can now pass both KB files.