Bemanistyle [dot] com Forums - View Single Post

#Infinity · 10-02-2006, 06:15 PM

I hoped for more from this thread. It got quite a few posts the day after I posted it, and then all of a sudden, it got abandoned. But since I felt like posting it as well, here are my choices more the most overrated/underrated OSC simfiles as opposed to my favorites:

Overrated:

- Be Princess - This was the first simfile from its bracket that I was not very impressed by. It's not the worst ever, as it does include nice graphics and good syncing, but I feel that it really didn't deserve to be in the finals.
- Cheap Trick Kinda Girl - IMO, either Jump, Emerald Sword, or Breathe should've won OSC 5's ITG division, not this. The background videos are a nice touch, but the artwork could've been better (particularly since it's an nDDRo simfile) and the mines were horribly overdone in places.
- Inspiration - Yes, I gave it a full score, but even then, I just don't believe it should've won the whole competition when it was merely just another generic eurobeat simfile, despite being made very well.

Underrated:

- Asteroid - Quite a fun ITG simfile, really. Too bad it only ranked 16th overall in the ITG bracket.
- Computer Oba-Chan - This is brilliant, and yes, I actually do find it to be quite funny to tell you the truth.
- Sakura Kaduki - It seems that outside of Discovolante, I was the only person who actually enjoyed this simfile. I gave it high grades because of its innovativeness, but many people found it to be extremely flawed.
- Way Of Life - This is pure genius. The cut may be too long, but it still brings in quite a unique style and has very fun steps.

10-02-2006, 06:15 PM	#9
#Infinity //bemanistyle::[Member] #Infinity is offline Join Date: Jun 2006 #Infinity's Collection Posts: 334 Marketplace Rating: 0 Tokens: 7,726.78 Bank: 0.00 Total Tokens: 7,726.78 Donate Tokens	I hoped for more from this thread. It got quite a few posts the day after I posted it, and then all of a sudden, it got abandoned. But since I felt like posting it as well, here are my choices more the most overrated/underrated OSC simfiles as opposed to my favorites: Overrated: - Be Princess - This was the first simfile from its bracket that I was not very impressed by. It's not the worst ever, as it does include nice graphics and good syncing, but I feel that it really didn't deserve to be in the finals. - Cheap Trick Kinda Girl - IMO, either Jump, Emerald Sword, or Breathe should've won OSC 5's ITG division, not this. The background videos are a nice touch, but the artwork could've been better (particularly since it's an nDDRo simfile) and the mines were horribly overdone in places. - Inspiration - Yes, I gave it a full score, but even then, I just don't believe it should've won the whole competition when it was merely just another generic eurobeat simfile, despite being made very well. Underrated: - Asteroid - Quite a fun ITG simfile, really. Too bad it only ranked 16th overall in the ITG bracket. - Computer Oba-Chan - This is brilliant, and yes, I actually do find it to be quite funny to tell you the truth. - Sakura Kaduki - It seems that outside of Discovolante, I was the only person who actually enjoyed this simfile. I gave it high grades because of its innovativeness, but many people found it to be extremely flawed. - Way Of Life - This is pure genius. The cut may be too long, but it still brings in quite a unique style and has very fun steps. __________________ Latest Simfile Release: Last edited by #Infinity : 10-02-2006 at 06:18 PM.