I find it irritating that threads asking for people to judge simfiles (weather it be for stepmania or any other rythym game) get closed. The reason given is because there is a comment box for each simfile. Truth is, many songs are overlooked or ignored for several reasons, one being that the song/title may not be appealing to others.
Constructive criticism allows the user to gain more knowledge on how to properly make song charts for others to enjoy. Allowing users to ask for feedback on their simfiles on the forums would enable more people to look at their work and give tips etc.
Right now people are limited to the comment box which hardly anyone posts in unless it's a really popular song (which doesn't do justice to the decent song charts out there).
example:
http://www.bemanistyle.com/forum/f93...ime-sim-30367/