View Single Post

Old 08-11-2006, 09:51 PM   #4
jesterline
//bemanistyle::[Member]
 
jesterline's Avatar
 
jesterline is offline
Join Date: Jun 2006
Posts: 150
Marketplace Rating: 0
Send a message via PM  to jesterline
Default

My judging might seem harsh, but I'd say a 6 = average. So if you think your score is low that's because my judging is kind of low, but it isn't as bad as it seems! Or something.

Also, I liked bracket 1 better. I'm weird.

----------

All In The Way - Sarina Paris

Steps: 4.5/6
It was good I guess, but nothing about it really stands out. It just kind of boring in

idea.

Everything Else: 2/4
The graphics are pretty bad. Weird bevels, and the base of it is ugly and doesn't really

fit.

TOTAL: 6.5/10

----------

Bouncin! - H-Corps

Steps: 4,5/6
It seems like you kept trying to do different things with this chart because of how

repetitive it is, which is good, but it felt weird sometimes. Also, you put freezes that

are so short that you don't need to even hold them to get the OK.

Everything Else: 1/4
The graphics are kind of "blah" with the blurry text and everything. Also, it's offsync.

The BPM is too fast, I think.

TOTAL: 5.5/10

----------

Dancin' In My Dreams - J. Storm

Steps: 4/6
The synthline was kind of awkward and strange, and the rest of the steps were kind of

"boring in idea" which I guess is my new phrase! Too jump, too, at points.

Everything Else: 3/4
The graphics are okay, kind of random anime girl and bg video but I'm sure they fit in

somehow! Right?

TOTAL: 7/10

----------

Do You Know (I Go Crazy) - Angel City

Steps: 4/6
I'm going to pull this one out again: boring in idea. It's pretty average.

Everything Else: 2/4
The graphics don't match the subtitle on the songwheel, which is pretty weird... The BG

is really blurry too.

TOTAL: 6/10

----------

Fuku Wa Uchi - Domino

Steps: 4.5/6
Good, kind of average. Nothing really stands out as amazing but it's good!

Everything Else: 4/4
Nothing wrong here.

TOTAL: 8.5/10

----------

Gasolina (Delaction Remix) - Danny Ray

Steps: 5/6
Finally I have some real feedback to give out. Some parts, I really like what you

did. Others, kind of strange. Mainly, the verse and chorus were kind of weird at points.

Still a fun chart, though!

Everything Else: 3/4
Weird graphics, mainly the background. Nice lyrics and everything, cool beans.

TOTAL: 8/10

----------

High School Love - DJ Yoshitaka feat. DWP

Steps: 4.5/6
I'm giving out a lot of 4.5s... These steps have a great idea but with some flaws. Like

when you put a jump on the really stressed beat, you would always put one on the silence

before it, which made no sense and did make it worse. Also right before that part with

the huge three stresses eighths, you put two jumps. Just follow it, it will be fine! You

definitely have talent and can make a really good chart!

Everything Else: 2/4
That background looks really pixelated and gross.

TOTAL: 6.5/10

----------

Inspiration - Eri

Steps: 6/6
Wow, this is definitely the best file of this competition. This is everything Dream Of

You should have been. It has the perfect combination of creative steps and steps that

follow the synth and... I don't really know what to say other than amazing job.

Everything Else: 4/4
The graphics are amazing, the song is amazing, it's just amazing. AMAZING!

TOTAL: 10/10
I didn't even know people made files this perfect. This is the winner of the contest.

----------

Kickstart My Heart - Motley Crue

Steps: 3.5/6
A lot of jumps, pretty crazy. Sometimes I didn't like the steps, sometimes they were

good. You were creative though, which is good. Yeah.

Everything Else: 1/4
This song could have been way shorter, the "chorus" was really repetitive and got

extremely boring and annoying after hearing it like 20 times. The graphics are also just

a cut and paste on a random generic 3D thing, which doesn't really fit the song, which

doesn't really fit DDR!

TOTAL: 4.5/10

----------

Little Little Princess - Shrine 418

Steps: 1.5/6
Ehh... this chart really had no flow at all. There were a lot of awkward gallops and

freezes that are too short to be held. Just not good sorry.

Everything Else: 1/4
BPM gimmicks... badly compressed/stretched graphics (not really sure which)...

TOTAL: 2.5/10

----------

Love Is Eternity (SF Synth Trance Mix) - Sota Fujimori

Steps: 2.5/6
You tried to follow the rhythms the whole time, but you really messed them up a bit

throughout the chart.

Everything Else: 4/4
On sync, nice graphics, nothing wrong really.

TOTAL: 6.5/10
This file reminds me of Ultramix. Take that how you want.

----------

Paranoia Sky - NW180

Steps: 5/6
This was really hard to rate. I didn't know if I should rate it as a Paranoia file or a

regular stepfile. It worked as a Paranoia file so you get a FIVE because it isn't all

that amazing but it's good.

Everything Else: 2/4
Bad graphics, and there are already enough Paranoias to go around.

TOTAL: 7/10

----------

Pump Up The Jam - Technotronic

Steps: .5/6
You follow the vocals and melody so close (and fails at it a lot) and it doesn't work at

all. I guess you'll get a ,5 for um... I don't know.

Everything Else: .5/4
When I think of Pump Up The Jam, I think of the 70s and the hair of a skunk. :X :X :X

It's on sync...? Too long...

TOTAL: 1/10

----------

Right Now (Dance Man Remix with The Bandman) - Atomic Kitten

Steps: 4.5/6
Kind of double steppy, but it actually worked. I don't know what to say about this, it's

a pretty good chart.

Everything Else: 3/4
The banner is absolutely impossible to read on the normal theme.

TOTAL: 7.5/10

----------

Sakura Kaduki - Akito

Steps: 1/6
You were trying to follow things that didn't exist in the song... and then a freeze note

orgy following something being plucked?

Everything Else: 2/4
I was going to say the graphics looked nice, but then I read your readme and saw that you

just took them from another game. Correct me if I'm wrong, because I'm kind of confused

about that.

TOTAL: 3/10

----------

Samba Brazil - Captain Jack

Steps: 3.5/6
Seems kind of messy. Pretty generic until the second chorus which was just kind of

strange.

Everything Else: 2/4
I don't know why you'd step a song called Samba Brazil and not at least use one color of

the Brazil flag. Not a big deal though. A big deal was the cut! What was with that long

section of percussion? That is not good for a DDR cut.

TOTAL: 5.5/10

----------

Seasons Of Love (Gomi's Lair Club Mix) - Rent

Steps: 2/6
This was mostly following the wrong things! A lot of weird things being followed in this

file. Usually it's trying to follow the vocals too closely. Also, freeze orgy!!! Why was

that last note like a 64th freeze?

Everything Else: 3/4
I can't really read the subtitle in the banner. The BG isn't bad and whatever.

TOTAL: 5/10

----------

Xe-sphere - Tatsh feat. K. Nayuki

Steps: 2.5/6
Not sure what's going on here. Really "messy" and weird. There's a lot to follow.

Everything Else: 1/4
Since when do we add BPM and genre to BGs? Also: BPM gimmicks and bad audio!

TOTAL: 3.5/10

----------

This Is Love - Utada Hikaru

Steps: 3/6
I liked the parts where there was a beat mostly. It seems like when the beat dropped

out/became more quiet you didn't really know what to do.

Everything Else: 4/4
Yeah nothing really wrong here! I like the graphics.

TOTAL: 7/10

----------

Together - Smile.dk

Steps: 5/6
These steps are very good! They don't totally stand out but they are really well done,

good job!

Everything Else: 3/4
The background was kind of boring, and the cut was kind of weird.

TOTAL: 8/10

----------

Tunak Tunak Tun Created by Dj ThugLife

I get this strong feeling that you aren't a thug considering you're making a stepfile and

it's to a Daler Mehndi song.

Steps: 1/6
Um, yeah. The TUNAK TUNAK TUN parts were crazy, too hard and off. The rest was pretty...

blah.

Everything Else: 1/4
Terrible graphics... Also you don't put your name on the songwheel no!

TOTAL: 2/10

----------

Way Of Life - Stylophonic

Steps: 2/6
You don't have to follow everything so closely!

Everything Else: 1/4
Went on for too long, atrocious graphics.

TOTAL: 3/10

----------

Wild Thing/Poor Boy - Prozzak

Steps: 5.5/6
Very good! I liked it a lot. I don't really no what to say other than it's quite good!

Everything Else: 3/4
The banner was pretty bad, and the background was kind of bad. But not too bad.

TOTAL: 8.5/10

----------

Wowowee - Willie Revillame featuring Lito Camo

Steps: 5,5/6
Predictable, to be honest, but I really think it works well for this song. It seems like

you were afraid to put in brakes a few times, though. Really good chart!

Everything Else: 3.5/4
The background seems a little weird, like more could be done. But it's good. I really

liked the banner, too. Perfect.

TOTAL: 9/10

----------

You Give Love A Bad Name - Mandaryna

Steps: 3/6
Really.. I don't know... average? It's kind of boring.

Everything Else: 2/4
Bad graphics, and for a while the BPM is doubled.

TOTAL: 5/10

----------

Nagai Yume - Yuki

Steps: 4.5/6
These were actually quite good. I didn't like some of the ending, though. I'm not sure what to say but it was pretty good.

Everything Else: 3/4
The text on the graphics is bad. BAD. Did the BG ever even show up? I don't know, um, but I looked at it and the text is bad. Yeah.

TOTAL: 7.5/10

Last edited by jesterline : 08-12-2006 at 09:46 PM.