TWG IV: Another Bad Horror Story (Day 2) - Page 10

Heavy Metal Hero · 10-22-2006, 08:03 PM

I say mark was used. It's the most obvious thing.

Also, I'm going to say something very dangerous that could get me lynched...here we go.

I say we go ahead with gasm's plan.

WAIT, wait, wait, hear me out. There are a few possibilities:

1) gasm is a wolf trying to lure out the seer.
2) gasm is legitimately human and was legitimately contacted, and wants to be sure.
3) gasm wasn't contacted, but is human/guardian/important guy who can watch the seer and get fed info.

Frankly, we've played a few games with gasm and we know how he does things. Generally, if he's doing something wolfy it's a sure sign he's human. I know that's ass-backwards logic, but let's face it: If we can use him to pull this off, humans are practically guarenteed winners. If we have someone being fed visions and guarded, chances are we'll hit wolf eventually since there are currently four in the game. Plus, we'll confirm humans and that's good.

This is a gamble, and I'm putting my neck on the line to suggest it, but I think we have a shot doing this. I mean, the guardian probably didn't hit the kill (at least, it's unlikely) which means there are now four wolves to like thirteen or fourteen people. In the untimely event that gasm is a wolfy bastard and playing us, we lose. If he's just being gasm-ish, we could trust him and probably win. Take your pick, I guess.

*TTRlovesMittens* · 10-22-2006, 10:12 PM

Just because I'm way too lazy to do a Random.org again, I'm voting Fletcher again

Vangulus The Great · 10-22-2006, 10:39 PM

Given gasm's track record in past games he always has an elaborate plan that may work if executed correctly but he always get lynched when he starts explaining it. Also he was always human during those times. This means either he's just being gasm or he's a wolf trying to throw us off and listen to him for once. Either way I'm holding my vote for now to see how this develops.

rmz · 10-23-2006, 01:50 AM

No kill last night?

Of course a mark was used; the wolves wouldn't be stupid enough to just say "hey, let's be nice and not kill anybody tonight." So, the question becomes who do we think they would mark? Someone obvious, perhaps, or someone less predictable so as to avoid kneejerk lynchings from the humans?

I'm still mulling over my vote choice for today, but it's something to discuss.

normac · 10-23-2006, 02:26 AM

I'm guessing gasm's take charge grand plan to root out the wolves makes him a human.

Starmony · 10-23-2006, 03:30 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by normac

I'm guessing gasm's take charge grand plan to root out the wolves makes him a human.

Or so you would think. anyway, i agree with HMH but i still dont see enought for me to cast my vote for anyone.

gasm · 10-23-2006, 07:58 AM

List of players:

Mystic (posted)
Excel-2006
Vangulus the Great (posted)
rmz (posted)
normac (posted)
Heavy Metal Hero (posted)
gasm (itsa me)
TTR_loves_Mittens (posted)
Neighbor Totoro (posted)
Fletcher
Solon Halwinder
m335h73r of /flex (posted)
GuyWithHat (posted)

Pretty much all of the players left have posted except for Solon, Fletcher, and Excel. And so far I haven't received any PMs from secondary seers.

When (if) those three post. I will be confirmed, since no one claimed against me. Then that would make me a confirmed human.

m335h73r of PBJ · 10-23-2006, 01:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by rmz

No kill last night?

Of course a mark was used; the wolves wouldn't be stupid enough to just say "hey, let's be nice and not kill anybody tonight."

I'm pretty sure given the track record of the wins the wolves had. (even if you only counted the number of shutout wolf victories) They could be so full of themselves they could just do nothing for a bit, and STILL win.

I'm mulling over some thoughts at the moment, I'll have my vote upon my next post.

Solon Halwinder · 10-23-2006, 02:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by rmz

No kill last night?

Of course a mark was used; the wolves wouldn't be stupid enough to just say "hey, let's be nice and not kill anybody tonight."

Not necessarily; with no kill, we have no idea who the wolves might have wanted to target, and from that, we have no further evidence as to who they might or might not be. The wolves in DDRFreak's Game 39 used the trick to great effect by only using one nightkill (N1) and forefiting all the rest of them.

@gasm: Take care. Take great care. Because of the nature of this game, you really don't have any way of knowing what the person who contacted you was, nor any way to know what anyone making a counterclaim is.

normac · 10-23-2006, 02:58 PM

It's too bad this game isn't as easy as "all the humans raise thier hands and let's lynch those who didn't."

Heavy Metal Hero · 10-23-2006, 06:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by normac

It's too bad this game isn't as easy as "all the humans raise thier hands and let's lynch those who didn't."

In many ways, it kind of is. We tend to kill indiscriminately here if there's the slightest suspicion of wolfiness, like gasm the past two games. We grasp at straws too early and then get nightkilled out.

ANGRY ABOUT ENGLISH · 10-23-2006, 08:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by gasm

Pretty much all of the players left have posted except for Solon, Fletcher, and Excel. And so far I haven't received any PMs from secondary seers.

Gimme a break, I check this thread bi-daily.

I will vote before midnight my time, I'm trying to puzzle a thing or two out.

Geschpooklichkeit · 10-23-2006, 08:44 PM

I can't make any judgments right now, so I'm going to vote normac. His avatar haunts me.

normac · 10-23-2006, 09:23 PM

Edit: My train of thought fell into a canyon.

gasm · 10-24-2006, 07:54 AM

So now everyone has posted since I posted my plan, and no one has counterclaimed. Unless someone wants to come out and say that they did contact me and I'm lying, that means I'm confirmed and so is the seer who contacted me.

Now I strongly suggest that the priest and guardian contact me, so I can put you in contact with the seer. And yes I know I need to wait for counter claims before I tell them who the seer is.