avatar - 4, because I know you can photoshop cause you photoshopped the signature, but you didn't touch the star trek photo. Do something to it to make it yours and not just a photo off of google.
signature (the one you posted) - 7, The signature with the girl isn't bad, it just doesn't stand out. It was too bright so the whole thing looks faded. If you make the girl darker and add contrast to the whole thing, it will look a lot better.
your actual signature - 9, I really like this signature, something is going on in the background, it's not just a flat color. I like the font you used. I just have two tiny suggestions to make it a ten. The first one is to move the words "stupid" and "jme" up a couple pixels cause they don't line up with the rest of the words, and my second one is that I would change the right of the picture from fading out to getting darker. I think the wholee photo would be a lot more effective if the right faded to black instead of white because the whole photo is kind of a grungy feeling.
__________________ |