its probably been beaten into the ground but...

[허드손]

That's completely opinion based. Maybe if you like generic techno and trance shit, then sure, IIDX is just AWESOME. But if you're looking for a much wider variety of music, and actually enjoy quirky Japanese songs other styles of music, then most pop'ns have stellar soundtracks. pop'n 15 actually comes to mind. pop'n 8, 9, and 10 were also all amazing, in my opinion.

[Compass]

Originally Posted by mengzor

Yet it still maintains a better proportion than IIDX imho.

Haha, we will have to agree to disagree on that one.

[mengzor]

Dunno , at least the good music in pop'n is catchy and sticks in your head abit. The music in IIDX just sounds abit :|
Even the Ryu* stuff which is (imo) the best stuff on IIDX sucks in comparison to alot of my favorite pop'n tracks

[Compass]

Ryu* is amazing. And I agree when Pop'n tracks are good, they're good.

But overall, I find IIDX songlists to be significantly better in the all-around department. I can spend two hours with a single style, and still not play all the songs I really like once. Contrast this with Pop'n, where after twenty minutes, I'm desperately hunting through the songlist to find anything passable.

[Badb]

Originally Posted by [NesS]

the first game i ever played was carnival and the songlist made me orgasm. fever didn't impress me. i just played high school love and let's go out!! all the time because the rest of the songs were not impressive to me.

Agreed. D8

Carnival personally seems a bit more well built in song-variety and appeal then FEVER. And it might be a bit better for someone whos not pretty adapted to Pop'n. Now granted, I only own Pop'n 9 and Carnival, so I cant directly say how bad/good FEVER is.

But I have the soundtrack to 14 and I can honestly say I enjoyed only a few tracks. xD

Carnival? They all made me implode. OwO

...But overall, I find IIDX songlists to be significantly better in the all-around department. I can spend two hours with a single style, and still not play all the songs I really like once. Contrast this with Pop'n, where after twenty minutes, I'm desperately hunting through the songlist to find anything passable.

...I slightly agree with this. IIDX does have some pretty quality stuff, but Pop'n does have some more catchier songs. ;/ (Arguable.)

[BemaniAK]

Originally Posted by mengzor

Yet it still maintains a better proportion than IIDX imho.

yeah, I can tell that by the fact that on IIDX 12 at my arcade, the only thing people play anymore is xepher...

[zorahk]

^ lol necroposting

but to reply I don't know why you guys hate on 14 because personally I really like hora de verdad, ubertreffen, blaaast!!!, fever robo, fever hero, on the CS side im addicted to romantic ga tomaranai, hashire scooter, etc etc, i mean honestly the song list is pretty good, although I dont see how it really fits the fever theme as well as the songs on carnival fit the carnival theme. actually 14 AC though has more of a fit to the "fever" theme I think, especially with dschinghis khan in the anime section as a revival from 10

[Snapps]

Carnival CS has the best songlist to choose from, in my opinion.

[MC FUMBLENUTS]

Originally Posted by Snapps

11 CS has the best songlist to choose from, in my opinion.

Fixchar

[Timer Rabbit]

Originally Posted by Snapps

Carnival CS has the best songlist to choose from, in my opinion.

I have to point the same to you. I own Carnival, and have to admit that the songs in CS + the CS-only songs are wonderfull....

(ButI like FEVER because of one song... I won't tell because it's ovious.)

[Brett]

Get neither. For the price of one of those games you could get a best hits version of popn 7/8/9/10. I would go with 9 and 10.

[hyper kitten]

I'd say get carnival for Moushima (XD) and Mars War 3