Bemanistyle #1 In music game coverage - Dance Dance Revolution, Beatmania, IIDX, Popn Music Sponsored Banner Ad. Contact Keith or Djp to AdvertiseSponsored Advertisement

Go Back   Bemanistyle [dot] com Forums > Bemani Simulation > DDR Original Step Contest
Tags: , , , ,

Reply
 
Thread Tools

DDR OSC BoNG Staff Applications
Old 10-21-2006, 05:22 PM   #1
Aeronautical Vigilante
Penguins can't fly!
 
Aeronautical Vigilante's Avatar
 
Aeronautical Vigilante is offline
Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: Alaska
Posts: 226
Marketplace Rating: 0
Tokens: 73,762.12
Bank: 0.00
Total Tokens: 73,762.12
Donate Tokens
Send a message via PM  to Aeronautical Vigilante
Default DDR OSC BoNG Staff Applications

Okay, so, here's the situation.

While I don't think that OSC 5 was quite as quagmirous (yes that's a real word) as, say, DDRei Tournamix 6, it had it's issues - not the least of them being a lot of people hating on the judges for one or more reasons. This means that a few long-term OSC volunteers have left the competition - including some of our most significant staff, including PlatinumHawke and BlueSS. I'm not going to discuss the specifics, if you don't know them already you can ask someone who does.

Either way, we need quite, quite, quite a new staff team for the upcoming competition, DDR OSC ~Beta of New Generation~. This event is going to serve three purposes:
  • First, it will be a small-scale competition, since there was a lot of demand for it. Keep in mind however, that I will be much tighter on enforcing rules about not causing drama. There will be no warnings during the duration of the next competition. Flaming, approaching flaming, or otherwise intending to spark drama or having the significant appearance thereof will result in one or more of: An Infraction (I can in fact issue them if the infracting post is made in this forum), a 10% penalty to your score (I'm not sure what the precise scale for new scorings will be), removal of your Public Review from the thread before calculations are made, or flat-out Disqualification from this and future OSC competitions.
  • Second, it will hopefully be a springboard to a project I still really wish to do - collaborative remakes of a bunch of classic OSC files from 1-4. Stuff that didn't go over the first time getting a second chance, some of the best stuff being reimagined under new schemes.
  • Third, it will be a beta test of the next-generation OSC rules. The original OSC rules are not even going to be a reference for the new set. Major features will include:
    1. Streamlined judging to help the judges do their work efficiently.
    2. Judging and Public Reviews following the exact same format, which will allow for (with reviewer permission) bumping of top-quality reviews to judge scores if there are absences.
    3. Somewhat tighter definitions of formats and rules.

A few other reforms I'm considering:
* A wiki-based (but not publically editable) database for rules, judgings - well, everything really.
* Merging DDR and ITG into a "pad" division, while keeping a separate Keyboard division. I'm really getting tired of shoehorning patterns as "DDR"and "ITG", when steps that are neither can be equally fun.
* Alternatively, creation of a THIRD pad division which is not format-limited. If we do this one, however, players will be limited to two divisions.
* There's probably some smaller stuff, and if people have ideas they should be brought up... But please not in this thread.

This thread, however, isn't to advertise what I'm thinking for the next competition. It's to get people to contribute.

As I said up top, we no longer have our tournament leader. We no longer have several of our judges (though I sincerely hope some of them will return).

Rather than go out and ask specific people to volunteer - I'm not even sure where to start - I'm going to ask people to post in this thread - public only will be a requirement - if they wish to contribute as a judge, or with administrative tasks. This will be open to anyone and everyone, even people whom I have previously said I would never allow to be involved (Virgo, lrxevan, etc.) - the only exception being banned people (for obvious reasons).

There are two groups of positions open, and people may volunteer for either or both.
* Administrators help to keep things going smoothly - basically, filling the hole BlueSS left behind. Duties include checking the files in to confirm they meet the rules, putting the files into packs for release, moderating the forum, and otherwise helping to keep things running smoothly. Administrators will also be asked to contribute to discussion of the rules.
* Judges will be in much the same position as before. Duties include downloading the files in a bracket, playing them reasonably thoroughly, assigning scores and justifying them, and then sending them in to the relevent Administrator or Administrators for compilation into scores.

Both also share the duty of being reasonably active on the OSC forums, helping to keep discussion positive, constructive, and silly as appropriate. Liberal use of is a must. (Not really.)

Applications are free-form, though I do request that you note whether you check your PMs often, or provide me another form of contact so I can chat with you specifically. You also have to nominate yourself - others can't nominate you. Things I'd encourage you to highlight:
* Past relevent experience
* Why you think you're suited for the position
* What specific tasks (or for judges, categories) you'd like to work with.
* If you have ideas for how the New Generation of Bemanistyle's competitions should run, you should name a few here just so we have an idea what you're thinking of.

Judges should consider the following categories: Keyboard, open Pad, DDR, ITG. Yes you can take multiple (and if you're doing anything besides Keyboard, you probably should). One possible reform may involve taking in more judges than we 'strictly' need (4 per bracket) - I do not want two-judge brackets again.

Administrators should consider the following tasks: Website (or possible database) maitenence, pre-release-to-judges simfile checking, compilation, or specializing in forum maitenence - if you can think of other things I'm forgetting, please let me know. All Administrators will be expected to provide input and ideas on the rules if they have any. Yes, you can take multiple tasks.

I will be continuing to handle at least some pre-checking, as well as score compilation and the final rules set, and HOPEFULLY being a judge for everything as well.

Finally, keep in mind positions are not binding. This means that you can opt to do this for JUST DDR OSC BoNG to help this particular one roll, and that you can be removed from the position if you're failing to attain basic objectives in it.

I request that applications sent in not be frivolous, and if you've used multiple names during competition history, please use your most commonly known name (i.e. lrxevan would be asked to submit as lrxevan, not Doctor Mango).

Current submissions under consideration:
jammitch! (Judge/Rules Checking)
#Infinity (Judge)
discovolente (Judge)
Lilina (Judge)
jesterline (Judge)
the_ditz (Judge)

Right now, without even really going over public review archives, I can out-and-out tell you that jammitch! and the_ditz are unequivocally in. I'll be going over review records for everyone else.

Anyone else who would give consideration to joining is asked to do so promptly. I would still like to have a co-administrator, for example.

I have chatted with certain specific individuals who have considered joining, and ask those individuals who have not posted here indicating that they wish to be considered for judging, promptly do so as soon as possible. I'll be formally inviting and/or interviewing staff soon, and then doing the rules.
__________________
Someday, I will find the flying machine!

Last edited by NekoIncardine : 11-14-2006 at 03:57 PM.
  Reply With Quote

Old 10-21-2006, 10:33 PM   #2
jammitch!
Requiem for Dissent
 
jammitch!'s Avatar
 
jammitch! is offline
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: Madtown, Cheeseland
Donated: $5 ?
Posts: 288
Marketplace Rating: 0
Tokens: 586.67
Bank: 8,653,230.58
Total Tokens: 8,653,817.25
Donate Tokens
Send a message via PM  to jammitch!
Default



I'd like to keep judging, and wouldn't mind having some input on the rules. I don't think I have the time or energy to administrate though (not a real word).
__________________
bring the dissident from slumber
raise the rebel from its grave
sound the revolution's thunder
a monumental blunder averted and betrayed

Download virtualVISIONS | Best of jammitch! Originals
  Reply With Quote

Old 10-21-2006, 11:39 PM   #3
#Infinity
//bemanistyle::[Member]
 
#Infinity's Avatar
 
#Infinity is offline
Join Date: Jun 2006
Posts: 334
Marketplace Rating: 0
Tokens: 8,306.58
Bank: 0.00
Total Tokens: 8,306.58
Donate Tokens
Send a message via PM  to #Infinity
Default

I desperately wish I could be among the judges for DDR OSC BoNG, even though I'm pretty new to the community. I believe I would be a strong choice for this job because:

- I'm very experienced with simfile designing and have only gotten better after participating in OSC 5. Ever since I discovered StepMania, I have been eager to create my own stepfiles, and over time, I have honed my skills to near-nDDRo ranks. I know much about what makes a good simfile.
- I have always enjoyed writing reviews and have become a contender at rating things over time. Check out my amazon.com review for DDR Extreme 2 for a sample (and that was a year ago, BTW; I have rapidly become more intelligent over time).
- I take things very seriously and am a hard worker. I would ensure that plenty of thought is put into my judge reviews.
- I always enjoy giving very constructive critisism in my reviews. Even if a simfile is as poorly-made as Tunak Tunak Tun, I'm still eager to kindly help the simfile creator to improve.
__________________
Latest Simfile Release:

Last edited by #Infinity : 10-21-2006 at 11:56 PM.
  Reply With Quote

Old 10-22-2006, 01:24 AM   #4
discovolante
Senior Bar Rapist
 
discovolante's Avatar
 
discovolante is offline
Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: Portland, OR
Posts: 303
Marketplace Rating: 0
Tokens: 3,903.62
Bank: 11,059.53
Total Tokens: 14,963.15
Donate Tokens
Send a message via PM  to discovolante
Default

I'd apply because I think I could write really comprehensive and possibly even helpful reviews. I won't because I don't think anyone "likes" my opinions.

I think #Infinity would be a nice addition to the judge pool.
__________________
Quote:
Originally Posted by pokecapn
discovolaaaaaaaaaaaaante you're breaking my heaaaaaaaaaaaaart
Quote:
Originally Posted by Xythar View Post
DISCOVOLAAAAAANTE
  Reply With Quote

Old 10-22-2006, 11:57 AM   #5
#Infinity
//bemanistyle::[Member]
 
#Infinity's Avatar
 
#Infinity is offline
Join Date: Jun 2006
Posts: 334
Marketplace Rating: 0
Tokens: 8,306.58
Bank: 0.00
Total Tokens: 8,306.58
Donate Tokens
Send a message via PM  to #Infinity
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by discovolante View Post
I'd apply because I think I could write really comprehensive and possibly even helpful reviews. I won't because I don't think anyone "likes" my opinions.
Don't worry. Opinion has nothing against the chances of you becoming a judge as long as you vividly state why you believe the song deserves the rating (also, don't rate too closely to ITG standards when reviewing DDR simfiles). Just look at some of the other ratings handed out by other judges. If you know about DDR OSC 4's second DDR Bracket, NekoIncardine rated Chocolate Philosophy (it didn't even come that close to making finals) as the best in the division, while giving Yellow Butterfly, which tied for 2nd in the finals, only a 68. But hey, at least he gave a detailed review for both songs to explain his opinion.

Go ahead, try to apply. You're exceptional at ITG and you're a fantastic step designer, so I'd greatly trust your "opinions".

Quote:
I think #Infinity would be a nice addition to the judge pool.
Why thank you. I'm glad I already have positive feedback for my application.
__________________
Latest Simfile Release:
  Reply With Quote

Old 10-22-2006, 01:40 PM   #6
discovolante
Senior Bar Rapist
 
discovolante's Avatar
 
discovolante is offline
Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: Portland, OR
Posts: 303
Marketplace Rating: 0
Tokens: 3,903.62
Bank: 11,059.53
Total Tokens: 14,963.15
Donate Tokens
Send a message via PM  to discovolante
Default

:swoon: ok!

I have way too much time on my hands almost all the time. If this is not the case during the time of judging, I WILL MAKE IT THE CASE. I will write 1000-word reviews if necessary for each simfile entered. I will explain my position on any aspect of a sim to the best possible depth, even (and especially) if it is a confusing or unpopular one. Furthermore, I like judging and I'll be able to get it done within deadlines.

So here's an official application for a judge position on DDR OSC BoNG!
__________________
Quote:
Originally Posted by pokecapn
discovolaaaaaaaaaaaaante you're breaking my heaaaaaaaaaaaaart
Quote:
Originally Posted by Xythar View Post
DISCOVOLAAAAAANTE
  Reply With Quote

Old 10-24-2006, 04:22 AM   #7
sinh(Lily)
SPACE FIGHT junkie
 
sinh(Lily)'s Avatar
 
sinh(Lily) is online now
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: University in the Philippines Diliman
Posts: 1,014
Marketplace Rating: 0
Tokens: 7,636.75
Bank: 1,500,010.56
Total Tokens: 1,507,647.31
Donate Tokens
Send a message via PM  to sinh(Lily)
Default

Since you did mention it last time in OSC5, I'm also considering judging (even handling the forums if possible).

Although I'm still refining my style in reviewing, as much as possible I try to give constructive and detailed reviews that as much as possible consider as many aspects of the file as possible, even when given a limited amount of time. Other than this, I'm very good with deadlines, especially since I was a former campus newspaper editor-in-chief (this is an advantage, right?), and my experiences in that field can help me not only in reviewing, but keeping track of schedules for OSC.

My judging specialty is more on DDR, though I can handle open pad fairly well.

As an administrator, my specialty is on compiling data (especially in judge brackets), forum administration (though I am not a mod here in Bemanistyle, yet, but I am available for at least 9-10 hours everyday), among others.

(Note: I do check Bemanistyle everyday, at least twice on a busy day. I'm usually available on YM. As for sked, I'm sure to be free the whole day on Wednesdays and Saturdays. As for MTThF, I usually have at least 8 hours of free time.)

Also, I think #Infinity deserves a post as judge, as well as discovolante. Its okay if people don't like your opinions, because we never really expect people to like what we say, especially in reviews. What matters is if people actually consider your opinion as a means to improve.

In addition...

Quote:
Originally Posted by discovolante
I have way too much time on my hands almost all the time. If this is not the case during the time of judging, I WILL MAKE IT THE CASE. I will write 1000-word reviews if necessary for each simfile entered. I will explain my position on any aspect of a sim to the best possible depth, even (and especially) if it is a confusing or unpopular one. Furthermore, I like judging and I'll be able to get it done within deadlines.

So here's an official application for a judge position on DDR OSC BoNG!
That's the spirit!!
__________________
Oh, lol. Simfiles XD.


Last edited by Lilina : 10-24-2006 at 04:29 AM. Reason: Avoiding doublepost
  Reply With Quote

Old 10-24-2006, 12:38 PM   #8
jesterline
//bemanistyle::[Member]
 
jesterline's Avatar
 
jesterline is offline
Join Date: Jun 2006
Posts: 151
Marketplace Rating: 0
Tokens: 1,875.56
Bank: 9.92
Total Tokens: 1,885.48
Donate Tokens
Send a message via PM  to jesterline
Default

If there is a seperation of pad styles, I'm open to judge the DDR bracket. I understand what makes good DDR styled simfiles. I won Tournamix 6 and got second in OSC5, of course. That's really all I have to say.
  Reply With Quote

Old 10-28-2006, 11:12 AM   #9
#Infinity
//bemanistyle::[Member]
 
#Infinity's Avatar
 
#Infinity is offline
Join Date: Jun 2006
Posts: 334
Marketplace Rating: 0
Tokens: 8,306.58
Bank: 0.00
Total Tokens: 8,306.58
Donate Tokens
Send a message via PM  to #Infinity
Default

I'd say that everyone so far who has made an application deserves a spot as a judge. If we end up using split divisions, I'd recommend Jammitch! and discovolante to judge for ITG, while Ebisumaru (not under the Jesterline alias) and Lilina would be great for DDR. I'd probably fall more under the DDR category, but feel free to get me to judge ITG if DDR ends up full, since I still frequently create ITG-style simfiles along with my DDR ones.
__________________
Latest Simfile Release:
  Reply With Quote

Old 10-29-2006, 08:35 AM   #10
the_ditz
//bemanistyle::[Member]
 
the_ditz is offline
Join Date: Jun 2006
Posts: 82
Marketplace Rating: 0
Tokens: 874.52
Bank: 0.00
Total Tokens: 874.52
Donate Tokens
Send a message via PM  to the_ditz
Default

I'm still available for judging any future OSC contests - you know my experience already since I've judged most contests here since OSC3...

In terms of categories, DDR will be my natural comfort-zone, but I do have a good understanding of what make a good ITG simfile as well (hell, I won the ITG division in OSC5) so I could help out with any pad-style divisions.

Contact me via PM on here or via email at the_ditz @ ddrextreme.co.uk
  Reply With Quote

Old 10-29-2006, 02:12 PM   #11
Juub005
//bemanistyle::[Member]
 
Juub005 is offline
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: Massachusetts
Posts: 191
Marketplace Rating: 0
Tokens: 496.78
Bank: 5,386.60
Total Tokens: 5,883.38
Donate Tokens
Send a message via PM  to Juub005
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by #Infinity View Post
I'd say that everyone so far who has made an application deserves a spot as a judge. If we end up using split divisions, I'd recommend Jammitch! and discovolante to judge for ITG, while Ebisumaru (not under the Jesterline alias) and Lilina would be great for DDR. I'd probably fall more under the DDR category, but feel free to get me to judge ITG if DDR ends up full, since I still frequently create ITG-style simfiles along with my DDR ones.
He has to be under the Jesterline alias. The whole reason he created that username is that someone else registered the username Ebisumaru before Bemanistyle 7.0 was even up.
__________________
  Reply With Quote

Old 10-29-2006, 07:13 PM   #12
Azure Haights
Oh no, it's Hitodeman!
 
Azure Haights is offline
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: Somewhere (is the place I've really got to be)
Posts: 123
Marketplace Rating: 0
Tokens: 57,390.30
Bank: 559,975.57
Total Tokens: 617,365.87
Donate Tokens
Send a message via PM  to Azure Haights
Default

(daruma) Ebisumaru

I say we hold a token fundraiser to get their names changed. If they don't take it put the tokens toward a OSC BoNG Hits prize.


Me: If there were to be a fundraiser to raise the tokens necessary to get both your and (daruma) Ebisumaru's names changed, would you take advantage of it
Me: Or just keep jesterline
the real Ebisumarmalade: i like jesterline haha

damn you jesterliiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiine
__________________

"Whoever did this is my hero. Just throwing that out there." --nomo, on Paranoia Survivor MIN

"Big noise!" --Omi

hey didder steps on the internets

Last edited by Azure Haights : 10-29-2006 at 07:18 PM. Reason: why don't we have :fistwave: yet
  Reply With Quote
Reply



Go Back   Bemanistyle [dot] com Forums > Bemani Simulation > DDR Original Step Contest
Thread Tools

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On

Sponsored Advertisement



All times are GMT -6. The time now is 04:28 AM.

vBulletin skin developed by: eXtremepixels
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.8
Copyright ©2000 - 2009, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
LinkBacks Enabled by vBSEO 3.1.0
| Home | Register | FAQ | Members List | Calendar | Today's Posts | Search | New Posts |